Mahmoud Farouk Gaber Gaber Sherif

This proposal is Interesting but confusing. Its proposal addresses landscape while at the same time, addresses big/tall buildings..it doesn't propose homes for families

This is really a Landscape Design only; that aspect has merit but doesn't really address the question. The built form seems rather random, reducing density which might make a district heating scheme, for instance, uneconomic

Great effort invested. Though; modest presentation and poor language made it difficult to digest the reasoning behind many of the decisions. I commend the sustainability focus, though I doubt some of the logic. For instance; If I am a resident, I would not fight heat this hard. I also have doubts about the feasibility of wind turbines. The respected designer did not highlight the cost factor of using scattered tall (e.g. steel structure) buildings VS low rise with cheaper structures. It is not clear the decision the designer made is analyzed using the correct variables.

The cut-away analysis is attractive but looks over complicated; a terraced solution would be better; the ‘plaza’ concept is out of sync with the context

Great addition to the city fabric

Definitely not my favourite. There's no detail. What would a house be like? west Belfast is full of failied housing estates. This one has to be different

A very good development for the nightbourhood

Terrific design

No es funcional

A GREAT HOPE TO THOSE WHO HAVE NO SHELTER

the whole idea is brilliant as he got the best advantage from the land and it's irregular shape the reuse of water ,all is briliant

Good design. Nice presentation

Good work 👏

Nice project 🤍🤍

Great on water recycling… but not keen on high rise buildings. Also not sure how melinis multiflora, and citrus maxima would do in Belfast either 😂

It's very good

It is perfect

Very nice

Perfect

wonderful. the urban solution of making it walkable without cars which will give the neighborhood a big park open for every one

Ok

Enormous form he dealed with an irregular shape of land with creative solutions creating new urban space for the people

Ok

will planed, master plan the idea of going vertical allowing for more residences and letting them have extra open space

Really smart the way they think about water. Not just using water but working in systems to constantly recycle and use water again to grow crops and feed the community.

The water recycling plan is terrific! I like the idea of a series of connecting plazas though more about what that would look and feel like would help

5 stars from me for the innovative plan to recycle water on the development!